The drug Ozempic, after just some years available on the market, has already develop into a family identify synonymous with weight reduction. The recognition of it and comparable medicines has skyrocketed so immensely and quickly that one drugmaker ran commercials telling individuals to cease utilizing the merchandise in the event that they’re solely seeking to drop a number of kilos.
It’s clear that these medication actually work, serving to individuals with weight problems lose way more weight on common than food regimen and train alone. And each week appears to deliver new findings on different potential advantages, similar to serving to forestall heart problems or treating drug dependancy.
However for some individuals, Ozempic and its ilk are merely the most recent iteration of a well-worn cautionary story: too-good-to-be-true weight reduction aids that can inevitably show to be harmful and even lethal. Maybe probably the most notorious instance is the drug mixture fen-phen, which was taken off the market within the late Nineteen Nineties after it was discovered to lift the danger of extreme, even life-threatening coronary heart issues. Whereas there are enduring classes to be realized from the saga of fen-phen, there are additionally a number of vital variations between it and the most recent technology of weight problems medication.
Fen-phen is brief for the medication fenfluramine and phentermine. Each are urge for food suppressants, however they work in several methods. Fenfluramine will increase ranges of serotonin, whereas phentermine primarily will increase ranges of norepinephrine—two neurotransmitters which have many vital roles, together with the regulation of urge for food.
Beginning within the Fifties, the medication had been individually permitted as short-term (a number of weeks) weight problems therapies. However on their very own, they solely appeared to assist individuals lose a bit extra weight than they might usually and got here with loads of irritating side-effects like dizziness, dry mouth, and hassle sleeping. In 1979, Michael Weintraub, then a professor of scientific pharmacology on the College of Rochester, had the idea of mixing the 2, reasoning that for the reason that medication affected the physique otherwise to suppress urge for food, they may have a good higher synergistic response that would additionally restrict side-effects by requiring a decrease dose.
Weintraub’s work testing fen-phen on his overweight sufferers appeared to substantiate the idea, showing that individuals taking the combo misplaced extra weight and maintained extra weight reduction than these on placebo, for up to four years and seemingly with no main adversarial results. It will take till 1992 for many of this analysis to be printed. As soon as it was, different docs quickly adopted fen-phen as their weight problems remedy of alternative.
By the mid-Nineteen Nineties, as many as 18 million prescriptions for the 2 medication had been being doled out yearly. In 1996, the makers of fenfluramine, American Residence Merchandise, acquired approval from the Meals and Drug Administration for a barely totally different model of the drug, known as dexfenfluramine and offered beneath the identify Redux, which additionally rapidly grew to become paired with phentermine. Redux was ostensibly an enchancment over the unique, although the approval would additionally cushion the corporate’s impending lack of its exclusivity over fenfluramine. The very subsequent yr, nonetheless, these plans got here to an abrupt halt.
In early 1997, 30-year-old Massachusetts resident Mary Linnen died from issues of pulmonary hypertension—issues that her household alleged had been attributable to her taking fen-phen for less than three weeks. Later that summer season, docs from the Mayo Clinic printed a paper discovering a hyperlink between fen-phen use of their sufferers and the emergence of coronary heart valve illness in addition to pulmonary hypertension. 5 of their sufferers wanted valve restore surgical procedure.
Pulmonary hypertension, or hypertension within the arteries connecting the guts to the lungs, had beforehand been documented as a possible uncommon side-effect of fenfluramine and comparable medication, however the uncovering of the guts valve threat was new. By that September, on the FDA’s request, American Residence Merchandise pulled each fenfluramine and dexfenfluramine off the market.
The basis trigger of those points was the elevated ranges of circulating serotonin introduced on by fenfluramine, which might be damaging to blood vessels and coronary heart valves. Some analysis has additionally suggested that the addition of phentermine may need contributed by rising serotonin ranges otherwise, although to not the identical extent as fenfluramine. That stated, phentermine alone has by no means been linked to both complication, nor was it ever recalled as an weight problems remedy.
There’s restricted information on simply how many individuals may need been harmed by fen-phen. However a 2000 research of over 1,000 sufferers found that 8.8% who took the drug combo had been later recognized with a minimum of gentle coronary heart valve illness, in comparison with 3.6% of a management group, with this threat going up the longer that they had been on the remedy. And following the recall of its medication, American Residence Merchandise would pay billions to settle lawsuits introduced in opposition to it by hundreds of former fen-phen sufferers, together with the household of Mary Linnen.
As severe because the disaster attributable to fen-phen was, although, there’s solely a lot that the drug combo has in widespread with the most recent weight problems medicines available on the market, Novo Nordisk’s semaglutide and Eli Lilly’s tirzepatide. For starters, the therapies work otherwise: Semaglutide and tirzepatide are a part of a category of medicine generally known as incretins, which mimic hormones vital to regulating our starvation and metabolism. This drug class has lengthy been used to handle kind 2 diabetes by serving to safely enhance insulin manufacturing that may maintain excessive blood sugar in test, with the primary product of its form (exenatide) permitted in 2005.
Over time, scientists have been in a position to create longer-lasting mimics of those hormones, resulting in the event of once-weekly semaglutide and tirzepatide. Semaglutide mimics GLP-1, whereas tirzepatide mimics GLP-1 and the hormone GIP. Each medication had been initially permitted for kind 2 diabetes and later as an weight problems remedy, with semaglutide offered beneath the names Ozempic and Wegovy, and tirzepatide beneath the names Mounjaro and Zepbound.
The cells that reply to those hormones are discovered each within the intestine and mind. Incretins are thought to tamp down urge for food not solely by bodily affecting the digestive tract, similar to by slowing digestion, however by interacting with these mind cells. The web result’s that individuals must eat much less meals to really feel full and really feel much less cravings for meals basically.
One other distinction between fen-phen and incretins is how these merchandise reached the general public. Whereas the halves of fen-phen had been permitted individually for weight problems, the drug mixture itself by no means was, with docs prescribing it off-label. This meant that fen-phen by no means underwent the intensive scientific trial course of that almost all medication available on the market at present, together with semaglutide and tirzepatide, did. The unique 1992 trial that sparked fen-phen’s recognition concerned 121 sufferers; in contrast, the Part III scientific trials of semaglutide and tirzepatide for weight problems have concerned hundreds of sufferers every, as did the trials for kind 2 diabetes.
Giant-scale scientific trials aren’t the one legitimate proof of a drug’s security, and incretins definitely have their very own unwanted effects. They’re recognized to generally trigger gastrointestinal signs like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea, for instance, although these signs appear to wane over time. However we merely have much more information on these medication than we ever did on fen-phen, courting all the way in which again to the earliest GLP-1s within the mid-2000s. And at present, the information is firmly of their favor.
Research haven’t solely discovered that the most recent medication reliably assist overweight individuals lose substantial weight (15% to over 20% physique weight over a yr’s time), however in addition they appear to scale back the danger of coronary heart and kidney problems in individuals at increased threat for them. Just lately, the FDA formally approved Wegovy as a remedy for stopping additional coronary heart assaults and strokes in overweight individuals with present heart problems. Some early analysis has additionally recommended that GLP-1s can scale back cravings associated to opioids and alcohol and that they may even have antidepressant effects.
“I feel, total, the advantages on glucose management, physique weight, the cardiovascular and the renal protections—they overcome any concern concerning the long-term use of those medicines,” Guillermo Umpierrez, a professor of medication within the division of endocrinology at Emory College College of Medication, instructed Gizmodo.
That isn’t to say that GLP-1s don’t have any drawbacks. Leaving apart the recognized and infrequently uncomfortable gastro signs, there’s some hypothesis, based mostly on animal information, that the medication may elevate the danger of a uncommon type of thyroid most cancers. Although this threat hasn’t been confirmed in human research—and a latest study of Scandinavians discovered no proof for a hyperlink—GLP-1s are nonetheless not really useful for anybody with a household historical past of this most cancers. And very like fen-phen, we do appear to be discovering new potential side-effects from GLP-1 use following their newfound recognition with the general public.
Some sufferers and docs have reported likely rare but serious complications similar to gastroparesis (abdomen paralysis), pancreatitis, and ileus (intestinal blockage) from taking these medication. Final September, the FDA discovered the studies credible sufficient to update its labeling of Wegovy and Ozempic to say the doable threat of ileus, although it didn’t affirm it as a longtime facet impact. Well being companies have additionally began to research a doable hyperlink between GLP-1 use and elevated suicidal ideation, although the FDA reported earlier this yr that it has not discovered sturdy proof of this connection, and a big EU investigation got here to an identical conclusion. The dramatic weight reduction skilled by sufferers may additionally trigger a big lack of lean muscle, which might elevate the danger of different well being issues. Although it’s still unclear whether or not these medication trigger extra muscle loss than any type of losing a few pounds would, some pharma corporations are already trying to find ways to counteract it.
Not each consequence tied to the emergence of GLP-1s is medical. Manufacturing issues and excessive demand have led to recurring shortages of semaglutide and tirzepatide, with many docs prescribing the diabetes manufacturers of those medication off-label for weight reduction. Consequently, some individuals with diabetes have been switched to different, probably much less efficient medication.
The shortage of provide, poor insurance coverage protection, and excessive checklist costs (over $1,000 a month with out protection) of those medication has additionally led to a gray and black market, with compounded and counterfeit variations now prominently marketed. Although these variations may be cheaper upfront, they don’t have any assure of security or effectiveness. Some individuals have ended up in the hospital from taking merchandise falsely labeled to comprise semaglutide, whereas others who aren’t overweight however taking GLP-1s to rapidly drop some weight may be placing themselves at risk. And a few sufferers who legitimately might be helped by these medication won’t reply to them or received’t be capable to tolerate the unwanted effects.
Maybe the important thing lesson of the fen-phen disaster is that each permitted medical remedy, regardless of how miraculous it might sound at first look, has its dangers. Docs, regulators, and the general public all play an element in maintaining watch and ensuring that the dangers of a drug don’t outweigh the advantages for the potential inhabitants of sufferers who take it. Ideally, when this does occur, companies just like the FDA can take motion to handle it, similar to by eradicating the drug from the market.
“Similar to we are saying to each affected person after we’re prescribing medicines, there’s nothing that we’ve prescribed that’s with out the potential for adversarial results. And a few of these adversarial results might not but be described,” Heidi Connolly, a heart specialist on the Mayo Clinic who was one of many first docs to find the hyperlink between fen-phen and coronary heart valve illness, instructed Gizmodo. “And so I feel it’s essential to be aware of any medicines which can be getting used and to look at sufferers for adversarial results.”
This steadiness between threat and profit is commonly difficult, although, and even once-villains like fenfluramine might be redeemed beneath the fitting circumstances. Whereas fen was receiving a lot of consideration for its weight reduction results within the Nineteen Nineties, some docs started to note that it additionally appeared efficient at reducing certain kinds of seizures in children. It will take many years and a number of other scientific trials, however in 2020, the FDA and well being regulators in Europe approved a model of fen as a remedy for seizures related to Dravet syndrome, a uncommon and extreme type of epilepsy that begins early in childhood; in 2022, it was additional permitted for treating seizures related to the same Lennox-Gastaut syndrome.
The drug now comes with a transparent warning of its hyperlink to coronary heart valve illness and pulmonary hypertension, and youngsters are required to recurrently bear testing to watch for these issues. However for these sufferers, who are likely to not reply to different medication, fen has as soon as once more develop into worthwhile. No less than in the intervening time, the identical might be stated for individuals taking the most recent weight problems medication as supposed.
Trending Merchandise
